The Kansas City Royals turned an ordinary ground ball into a costly setback Tuesday night against the New York Mets, resulting in one of the most unusual scoring plays of the MLB season. With runners on first and second, Mets outfielder Carson Benge hit a slow chopper toward the mound. Royals pitcher Seth Lugo fielded the ball but made an off-balance throw that sailed wide of first baseman Jac Caglianone, marking the first of three errors on the same play. These errors allowed Benge to reach safely and ultimately score, giving the Mets an early three-run lead before Kansas City even came to bat.

The Mets accepted the gift, jumping ahead 3-0 thanks to the Royals' defensive meltdown. This sequence stands out as a historic moment for Kansas City, highlighting a rare and costly defensive lapse.

Carson Benge had recently celebrated a solo home run against the Atlanta Braves on July 6, 2026, showcasing his offensive contributions to the Mets.

Sources