Nevada rancher Adrienne Snow recalls horseback rides across the high desert with military helicopters overhead, a scene she described to the Daily Caller as capturing “what being an American feels like.” For decades, ranching families in Churchill County have raised cattle beneath the flight paths of Naval Air Station Fallon, home to the Navy’s elite TOPGUN program.

However, Snow and eight other ranching families now contend that the Navy’s substantial expansion of the Fallon Range Training Complex threatens to destroy their long-standing operations. They argue the compensation offered falls far short of their actual losses.

The Navy has proposed $1.48 million to the Snow family for projected losses over a 100-year period. Yet, ranchers like Lahontan allotment rancher Justin Snow expressed strong dissatisfaction, telling the Intergovernmental Executive Committee in March, “You’re breaking me as a rancher right now. You’re going to take my ranch and pay me $14,000 a year … Unacceptable.”

Congress approved a scaled-back version of the Navy’s original expansion plan in the Fiscal Year 2023 National Defense Authorization Act after extensive negotiations involving federal officials, tribes, and ranchers. This legislation transferred approximately 489,000 acres of Bureau of Land Management property to Navy control for expanded training ranges.

The project, initially delayed due to COVID-19, was reinstated and ultimately signed into law by President Joe Biden in December 2022.

Navy officials stated to the Daily Caller that their appraisal and compensation methods “adequately account for all losses under the law as a result of the withdrawal or other national defense-related use.” They emphasized that their valuation process includes a 100-year timeframe for projecting grazing-related losses and determining payment amounts to affected permittees.

Sources