Former President Donald Trump has been permitted to proceed with his libel lawsuit against The New York Times, Penguin Random House, and three authors in the Middle District of Florida, according to a ruling by Judge Steven Merryday. The case involves allegations of defamatory statements about Trump's early life and business career published in two articles and a book.

Although the materials were researched, written, and edited in New York, they were distributed nationwide, including in Florida. Trump, who resides in Southern Florida and maintains a business presence in the Middle District of Florida as cofounder and majority shareholder of Trump Media & Technology Group (TMTG), claims that the publications caused reputational and economic injury within that district. Specifically, defendants distributed approximately 3,000 print copies of the articles, around 2,200 copies of the book, and the articles were viewed by about 45,000 unique online readers in the district.

The court found venue proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(a)(2), which allows filing in any judicial district where a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claim occurred. The ruling emphasized that a plaintiff need not select the venue with the most substantial nexus, only one where a substantial part of the events occurred. The court rejected arguments that the Florida venue was improper despite the defendants’ connections to New York.

Defendants have sought to transfer the case to New York, citing key witnesses located there, including former NBC Entertainment President Jeff Zucker, Mary Trump, and several former Trump Organization executives. However, under Section 1404(a), such a transfer requires clear specification of key witnesses and their testimony's significance.

The lawsuit continues in the Middle District of Florida, marking a significant development in the ongoing legal disputes involving Trump and major media entities.

Sources