In a recent appeal decided on July 31, 2026, the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court addressed whether personalized license plates issued by Virginia constitute government speech or private speech protected by the First Amendment. The case involves Curtis Whateley, who applied for a personalized plate displaying the characters "FTP&ATF," an acronym he explained as "Fuck the Police & Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms."

Virginia initially issued the plate but later revoked it, citing concerns that the message was vulgar and could be interpreted as promoting violence. The court, led by Judge Pamela Harris and joined by Judges Agee and Keenan, recognized that this issue has divided courts in recent years.

The central legal question is whether the state speaks through the personalized plates it issues—allowing it to restrict messages as government speech—or whether the plates convey the private speech of drivers, which would require government restrictions to comply with First Amendment protections.

The Fourth Circuit concluded that Virginia's personalized license plate messages are private speech subject to First Amendment protection. However, the court noted that whether Whateley will prevail depends on the nature of the forum Virginia provides for such speech and the state's reasons for revoking the plate.

The court referenced prior rulings, including a 2016 Maryland case that treated personalized plates as private speech subject to First Amendment scrutiny but upheld denial of certain messages as reasonable restrictions in a nonpublic forum. It also cited a 2019 Kentucky case where denial of a personalized plate reading "IM GOD" was found to violate First Amendment limits due to viewpoint discrimination.

The decision underscores the complexity of forum analysis in cases involving personalized license plates and free speech rights.

Sources